• My account
  • Cart
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • YouTube

The Coeur d'Alene Coop

Raising Chickens and Urban Gardening

  • Home
  • About Our Heirlooms
    • About Candace
  • Garden Consulting
  • Shop
    • NEW/RETURNING for 2025
    • NEW! Culinary Planters
    • NEW! Flowers
    • Grown from Organic Seed
    • Heirloom Tomatoes
    • Heirloom Peppers
    • Heirloom Vegetables
    • Cool Season Vegetables
    • Herbs
    • Container/Small Space
    • My Favorites!
  • CdA Coop Blog
    • Gardening
      • Soil and Compost
      • Garden Seed Series
      • Growing Tomatoes Series
      • Growing Garlic Series
    • Backyard Chickens
    • Recipes
    • Garden Glossary
      • How Often to Divide Perennials & Winter Care
      • Q/A Sheet: How to Decide What to Grow in Your Garden
      • Ripe for the Picking: A Quick List of Common Fruit and Vegetables to Ripen On or Off the Vine
      • Vegetable Plant Family Chart
      • Seed Starting Charts
  • Contact Us
You are here: Home / Gardening / Organic Vs. Conventional Gardening: Which Is Better For Your Home Garden

April 3, 2025 By Candace Godwin Leave a Comment

Organic Vs. Conventional Gardening: Which Is Better For Your Home Garden

If you’ve visited a nursery or garden center, you’ve surely noticed plants, soil, and garden products labeled as organic. But what does “organic” really mean when it comes to gardening? How does it differ from conventional methods, and will using organic products make your garden healthier?

Understanding the differences between organic and conventionally grown seeds, soil, and fertilizers can help you make informed choices for a more sustainable and resilient home garden.

Conventional vs. Organic

Seed crops (grown for their seeds) can remain in the ground much longer than edible crops. The longer a crop remains in the field, the greater the opportunity for pests and disease to strike.

A good example is the carrot plant, a biennial with a two-year life cycle. For an edible crop, the carrot plant produces its fruit (the carrot) in about 70 days in the first year. However, for a seed crop, the plant is left in the ground until the second year, when it will flower and produce seed before dying off.

This extended growing time increases the risk of pests and diseases, so growers apply more chemicals over a longer period to reduce pest risk.

Most seed crops harvested are eventually used to grow food, but because they are not grown for human consumption, they are not subjected to the same regulations as food crops. The regulations are much less stringent and allow for a greater application of chemicals during the growing process.

Conventional growing methods often rely on synthetic fertilizers and potentially harmful pesticides to ensure a crop succeeds, be it seeds or food crops. The land, seed crops, and resulting plants are often treated with various chemicals beginning with a pre-emergent herbicide applied to the soil and continuing through harvest, when seeds may be treated with additional fungicides before packaging.

The liberal application of chemicals to conventionally grown seed (and plants) can lower resiliency, making them less able to fight pests and disease independently, especially compared to organically grown seeds and plants.

In contrast, certified organic seed comes from plants cultivated under strict organic growing protocols set by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA). While USDA organic practices permit certified organic pesticides and fertilizers, the choices available are significantly more limited than those accessible to conventional growers.

Organic growers prioritize healthy soils, integrated pest management techniques, and minimizing chemical use in their growing systems to produce healthy plants. This approach leads to seeds and plants that are naturally more vigorous and resilient against pests and diseases.

While pests and diseases can affect organic fields, growers select only the strongest, most resilient plants for seed harvesting. Ultimately, this results in stronger, more resilient organic plants.

Benefits of Organic Soils and Reducing Synthetic Fertilizers in Home Gardening

For home gardeners, choosing organic seeds is just the first step in creating a thriving, sustainable garden. The soil you use plays a critical role in the health of your plants. Organic gardening prioritizes soil health using compost, natural amendments, and cover crops to build nutrient-rich, well-structured soil. Healthy soil supports robust plant growth and reduces the need for expensive chemical inputs.

When selecting soils for raised beds or containers, look for the Organic Materials Review Institute (OMRI) seal that ensures the product is approved for organic gardening.

Non-organic or synthetic fertilizers provide a quick nutrient boost for your plants but may lead to soil degradation over time. It’s like giving your plants a quick “sugar fix.” They get that boost but still require more to sustain their growth.

Synthetic fertilizers also diminish beneficial microbial activity and organic matter in the soil biome, increasing plants’ reliance on external inputs and their vulnerability to disease.

Home gardeners can enhance soil fertility and support beneficial soil organisms by utilizing organic soil amendments like compost, worm castings, and aged manure.

Reducing synthetic fertilizers also helps the environment. Excess synthetic fertilizers frequently wash into waterways, leading to pollution and harmful algal blooms. Organic methods like composting and mulching retain soil moisture and nutrients while minimizing runoff and pollution.

Small Steps Make a Difference

By making small adjustments to your gardening methods—such as selecting organic seeds and plants, using organic soil amendments, and limiting synthetic fertilizers and pesticides—you can cultivate a healthy, productive garden that benefits you and the environment.

Organic gardening techniques, including crop rotation, companion planting, and natural pest control, further enhance soil and plant health while reducing chemical dependency.

Ultimately, embracing organic gardening leads to more vigorous plants, healthier soil, and more nutritious homegrown food. Whether you go fully organic or incorporate a few key practices, every step toward reducing synthetic inputs contributes to a more sustainable and rewarding gardening experience.

Filed Under: Gardening Tagged With: compost, conventional farming, organic farming, organic fertilizer, organic gardening, organic seeds, seed starting, soil fertility, synthetic fertilizer

Get Garden Tips & More

« How One Packet of Tomato Seeds Launched A Gardening Business
Budget Gardening Hacks: Grow More for Less with These Simple Tips »

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts from The Coop

  • Why Plan Your Fall Veggie Garden Now! June 6, 2025
  • How to Create Resilience in the Garden June 5, 2025
  • Dig In and Branch Out with Local Garden Resources May 30, 2025

Search Our Plants Here

Shop by Category

Cart

the coop on facebook!

The Coeur d'Alene Coop The Coeur d'Alene Coop updated their cover photo.

2 weeks ago

The Coeur d'Alene Coop
The Coeur d'Alene Coop's cover photo ... See MoreSee Less

Photo

View on Facebook
· Share

Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linked In Share by Email

the coop on instagram!

thecoeurdalenecoop

#thecoeurdalenecoop
@thecoeurdalenecoop
Heirloom tomatoes 🍅🍅
Organic gardening 🥕🌶
& Urban chickens! 🐔🐓

Brushed into a recent hatch of spiders sunning on Brushed into a recent hatch of spiders sunning on a hosta leaf...yikes! Hundreds of babies scrambling. 🕸🕷

#thecoeurdalenecoop 
#spiderbabies 
#spiderhatchlings 
#beneficialspiders 
#beneficialinsects
Follow on Instagram

Join the Flock!

Sign up to get gardening & chicken keeping tips delivered to your inbox.

Copyright © 2025 The Coeur d'Alene Coop · Coeur d'Alene, Idaho 83814 · Privacy Policy · Log in
Website Design: Godwin Marketing Communications LLC